Skip to main content
Blackfly The Restaurant logo top - HomepageBlackfly The Restaurant logo scroll - Homepage
  • (904)-201-6300
  • blackfly.nick@gmail.com
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs
  • Gift Cards
  • Events
  • Reserve
  • Facebook page
  • Instagram page
  • Google page
Blackfly The Restaurant logo top - HomepageBlackfly The Restaurant logo scroll - Homepage
  • Facebook page
  • Instagram page
  • Google page
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs
  • Gift Cards
  • Events
  • Reserve

Our Menu

  • Dinner Menu
  • Dessert Menu
  • Specials Menu

Starters

Blackfly Bread Service & Spreads
$8.00

Served with herb oil and sun-dried tomato butter.

Gluten Free
Cheese Bread Sticks
$12.00

Thinly stretched pizza dough with garlic, herbs, and Parmesan, with marinara.

Blistered Shishito Peppers
$14.00

Russian roulette peppers blistered in our brick pizza oven, served over arugula, with a lemon aioli and black lava sea salt.

Gluten Free
Bahamian Conch Fritters
$16.00

House-made fritter batter, blended with fresh conch and aromatics, served with datil remoulade.

Scallops Ryō
$24.00

(3) Sea scallops, chilled chai spiced apples, finished with a walnut-chili crunch and honey-sake reduction.

Gluten Free
Spicy Tuna Roll
$21.00

Spicy tuna blend, cucumbers, and carrots, wrapped in nori and sushi rice, topped with sashimi tuna, pickled Fresno chilis, red tobiko, kabayaki and chili oil, crystalized ginger, wasabi mousse.

Gluten Free
Black Forest Sprouts
$18.00

Crispy fried Brussel sprouts, tossed in a white balsamic vinaigrette, Black Forest bacon, dried tart cherries, walnuts, goat cheese crumble.

Gluten Free
Haitian Calamari
$18.00

Fried squid and artichokes, Haitian-inspired datil pikliz, and our classic Scotch bonnet aioli.

Maine Lobster Egg Rolls
$26.00

Butter-poached Maine lobster, shredded Napa cabbage and carrots, wrapped in wonton wrappers, lightly fried, served with a side of sweet chili glaze.

Chili - Lime Shrimp
$15.00

Shrimp in a spicy chili-lime garlic sauce, miso butter emulsion, and sweet soy.

Gluten Free
Spinach & Artichoke Dip
$17.00

Our touch on the classic, with fresh spinach and chopped artichokes, cayenne, garlic, and turmeric, baked with a cheese blend and served with corn tortillas.

Gluten Free

Soups & Salads

Bottled VOSS Still & Pellegrino Sparkling Water Available

Bahamian Conch Chowder
$10.00
Gluten Free
Soup of the Day
MP
Caesar Salad
$12.00

Chopped romaine hearts, garlic-herb baked croutons, shredded Parmesan, creamy Caesar dressing.

House Salad
$12.00

Spring mix, heirloom cherry tomato, carrot, cucumber, white balsamic vinaigrette.

Gluten Free
Mexican Street Corn Salad
$14.00

Fresh baby spinach, grilled then shaved Mexican style corn, Cotija cheese, tomatoes, red onion, warmed chorizo vinaigrette, cilantro-lime aioli, corn tortilla straws.

Isla Fresa Salad
$14.00

Assorted mixed greens, fresh mango salsa, goat cheese, cashew crumble, sweety drop peppers, white balsamic vinaigrette.

Gluten Free
Grilled Chicken
$9.00
Grilled Shrimp (4)
$9.00
Grilled Fresh Catch
Crispy Skin Salmon
MP
Furikake Crusted Seared Ahi Tuna
MP

Entrees

Red Snapper
$38.00

Seared, skin-on red snapper, lightly blackened, jasmine rice, vegetables, mango and jalapeno salsa.

Gluten Free
Datil Pepper Linguica
$26.00

A Caribbean twist on bangers and mash, grilled Portuguese style sausage, blended with local datil peppers, served with mashed potatoes, vegetables, and chimichurri.

Gluten Free
Furikake Crusted Ahi Tuna
MP

Seared rare, jasmine rice, house pickled vegetables, miso butter emulsion, sweet soy reduction, chili oil and wasabi.

Seafood & Grits
$39.00

Seared shrimp and scallops, served over Asiago cheese polenta, vegetables, tomato-fennel jam, chorizo-Cotija crumble.

Chicken Parmesan
$33.00

Italian breaded chicken breast, lightly fried, then topped with mozzarella and marinara, served with herb and garlic butter pasta and vegetables.

Surf & Turf Fried Rice
$38.00

Beef tips and shrimp sautéed in a spicy chili glaze served over vegetable fried rice, finished with fried garlic, miso butter emulsion, chili oil and sweet soy.

Rock Shrimp Capellini
$37.00

Florida rock shrimp, angel hair, garlic, red pepper flake, fresh basil, white wine cream, garlic crostini.

Triggerfish
$36.00

Pan-seared triggerfish, served over jasmine rice, vegetables, and lemon-caper beurre blanc.

Gluten Free
BlackFly Fried Shrimp
$28.00

(7) Jumbo fried shrimp, served with French fries, vegetables and datil remoulade.

Slammin' Salmon
$38.00

Togarashi-spiced, crispy-skinned salmon fillet (cooked medium), topped with a spicy chili aioli blended with lump crab, served with jasmine rice, vegetables, miso butter emulsion, wasabi and sweet soy.

Maine Lobster Mac & Cheese
$49.00

Maine lobster meat, sautéed with red onion, in a Vermont white cheddar-truffle Mornay sauce topped with a Maine lobster tail, served with garlic crostini.

Spicy Cashew Beef
$39.00

Chili marinated flank steak, grilled medium, sliced and served over Thai cashew sauce, served with jasmine rice, vegetables, green onions, and sesame seeds.

Autumn Farfalle
$28.00

Our signature vegan dish; bow tie pasta, sautéed with apples, fennel, sage, and pistachios, tossed in a butternut squash puree with Peruvian sweet drop peppers.

Vegetarian
Chicken Hastings
$29.00

Buttermilk-dill soaked chicken thighs, lightly fried, served with bacon confit savoy cabbage, malt vinegar fried potato nest, sweet corn puree, topped with Minorcan Mike's datil sauce.

Delicious Entrée Additions

Grilled Shrimp (4)
$9.00
Maine Lobster Tail
$24.00
Pan Seared Sea Scallops (3)
$18.00
Butter Poached Rock Shrimp
$14.00

Blackfly Grill

Select meats are served with your choice of mashed potatoes or French fries, seasonal vegetables, and a choice of sauce.
Add Chili Lime Glaze, Miso Butter Emulsion, Chimichurri, Sweet Soy +$9.00 | Make It Dynamite Style +$15.00 | Additional Sides of Sauces +$1.50

Grilled 10 oz. NY Strip
$44.00
Gluten Free
Grilled 8 oz. Beef Tenderloin
MP
Grilled 14 oz. Bone - In Pork Chop
$38.00
Sauce Options:

• Truffle Butter (GF)
• Thai Cashew Sauce (GF)
• Tomato-Fennel Jam (GF)
• Chimichurri (GF)

10" Brick Oven Pizzas

All pizzas are topped with a Provolone/mozzarella cheese blend.
All pizzas are made to order and come from a different area of the kitchen. They will come to the table when they are ready, not with other food ordered.

Margherita
$19.00

Crushed San Marzano tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, torn basil.

Vegetarian
Mediterranean
$21.00

Green olives, spinach, roasted red peppers, artichoke hearts, goat cheese, garlic oil.

Vegetarian
Mushroom
$22.00

Roasted mushrooms, red onions, truffle oil, basil, goat cheese.

Vegetarian
Chicken & Arugula
$22.00

Garlic and truffle oil, grilled chicken, ricotta, mozzarella, oregano, black pepper, fried garlic, fresh arugula.

Carnivore
$24.00

Pepperoni, bacon, Italian sausage, crushed San Marzano tomato sauce.

Blackfly Supreme
$26.00

Pepperoni, Italian sausage, roasted red peppers, mushrooms, and onions, green olives, mozzarella, and Asiago cheeses, basil-marinara base, oregano.

Sausage & Asiago Pizza
$23.00

Italian sausage, pesto, shaved Asiago cheese, red onion, roasted red peppers.
Add Anchovies or Truffle Oil +$3.00 | Add Bacon, Pepperoni, or Italian Sausage +$5.00 | Add Grilled Chicken, Grilled Shrimp or Linguica Sausage +$9.00

Desserts

Crème Brûlée
$13.00

Chef's inspiration flavor of custard, caramelized raw sugar, with a dollop of whipped cream.

Gluten Free
Triple Fudge Brownie
$15.00

Decadently delicious, served a la mode with vanilla ice cream, finished with salted caramel.

Cinnamon - Whiskey Peach Cobbler
$14.00

Our staff's favorite! Cinnamon whiskey braised peaches, baked with a buttery crumble, served a la mode with vanilla ice cream, and warm salted caramel.

Key Lime Pie
$14.00

This will take you back to Key West! Made with freshly squeezed key limes and a graham cracker crust, finished with whipped cream, a strawberry puree, and coconut chantilly.

Crostata de Napoli
$16.00

Dark chocolate tart, pistachio cream, dark cherry pearls, whipped cream, shaved chocolate.

Celebration Cake
$12.00

Whipped vanilla ice cream, layered between coconut crumble cake, garnished with firework crispies.

Menu

Crème Brûlée
$9.00

Today's flavor. Chef's suggested dessert wine pairing: Dow's 20 Year Tawny, $12.00

Triple Chocolate Fudge Brownie
$12.00

Vanilla ice cream, salted caramel. Chef's suggested dessert wine pairing: Fonseca "Bin 27" Finest Reserve, $7.00

Banana Bread Pudding
$10.00

Served with vanilla ice cream and hot bourbon caramel, topped with pecan streusel. Chef's suggested dessert wine pairing: Susana Balbo LH Torrontes, $12.00

Key Lime Pie
$12.00

Key lime pie made with fresh-squeezed key limes, graham cracker crust, whipped cream, strawberry puree, and coconut chantilly. Chef's suggested dessert wine pairing: Fonseca 10 Year Tawny, $10.00

Strawberry Semifreddo
$13.00

Chocolate mirror glaze, white chocolate sauce, strawberry puree. Chef's suggested dessert wine pairing: Ferrari Carano Eldorado Noir, $9.00

Ice Cream

$3.00 | $6.00 • 1 or 2 scoops | Choices: vanilla, toasted coconut, sorbet du jour.

Dessert Wines

Ferrari Carano, Eldorado Noir, California, Russian River Valley
$9.00
Susana Balbo, LH Torrontes, Argentina, Mendoza
$12.00
La Fleur Renaissance, Sauternes, France, 2016
$12.00
Felsina, Vin Santo Chianti Classico, Italy, 2007
$16.00

Port & Sherry

Taylor Fladgate, Ruby Porto, Portugal
$6.00
Sandeman, "Armada" Cream Sherry, Spain
$7.00
Fonseca, "Bin 27" Finest Reserve, Portugal
$7.00
Fonseca, 10 Year Tawny, Portugal
$10.00
Taylor Fladgate, 10 Year Tawny, Portugal
$10.00
VOS Jerez, Valdespino Solera Sherry, Spain
$12.00
Dow's, 20 Year Tawny, Portugal
$12.00

Cognacs & Brandy

Paul Masson VS Brandy
$8.50
D'usse VSOP Cognac
$9.50
Remy Martin VSOP Cognac
$10.50
Courvoisier VSOP Cognac
$14.00

Cordials

B&B
$8.75
Belle de Brillet
$10.50
Benedictine
$8.75
Campari
$7.50
Chambord
$7.75
Chartreuse - Green
$10.00
Disaronno Amaretto
$7.50
Domaine de Canton Ginger
$10.00
Drambuie
$9.50
Fernet Branca
$7.00
Frangelico
$7.75
Galliano
$8.00
Grand Marnier
$9.50
Carolans Irish Cream
$7.25
Licor 43
$7.50
Molinari Sambuca
$8.00
Patrón XO Café
$7.50
RumChata
$7.25

Specials Menu

Snow Crab Sundays

Simple. Fresh. Incredible. Join us every Sunday for sweet, succulent Snow Crab served hot and ready. The perfect way to end the weekend.

Prime Rib Tuesdays

Slab and a cab!
Featuring Hess Cabernet Sauvignon Half Bottle $29.00 | 12 oz. Prime Rib $48.00

Vegetarian
Gluten Free

Location

Blackfly The Restaurant
410 Anastasia Boulevard
St. Augustine, FL
32080
Get Directions

Hours

Mon, Tue, Wed, Thur
4:00 PM - 9:00 PM
Fri
4:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Sat
10:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Sun
10:00 AM - 9:00 PM

Find us on...

Facebook pageInstagram pageGoogle page

Contact us

Call us at (904)-201-6300

Write us at blackfly.nick@gmail.com

  • Reserve
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs